### Critique of the neoclassical theory of growth and distribution

#### Abstract

The paper surveys the main theories of income distribution in their relationship with the theories of economic growth. First, the Classical approach is considered, focusing on the Ricardian theory. Then the neoclassical theory is discussed, highlighting its origins (Bohm-Bawerk, Wicksell, Clark) and the role of the aggregate production function. The emergence of a "Keynesian" theory of income distribution in the wake of Harrod's model of growth is then recalled together with the surprising resurgence of the neoclassical theory (following the contributions of Solow and Meade). But, as the paper shows, the neoclassical theory of income distribution lacks logical consistency and has shaky foundations, as has been revealed by the severe critiques moved to the neoclassical production function. Mainstream economic literature circumvents this problem by simply ignoring it, while the models of endogenous growth exclude the issue of distribution theory from their consideration. However, while mainstream economics bypasses the problems of income distribution, this is too relevant an issue to be ignored and a number of new research lines, briefly surveyed, try new approaches to it.

**JEL Codes: **O41, E25, O33, B22

#### Keywords

#### Full Text:

PDF#### References

ALESINA, A. e D. RODRIK (1994), "Distributive politics and economic growth", Quarterly Journal of Economics, vol. 109, pp. 465-90.

ALLEN, R.G.D. (1967), Macro-economic Theory, Macmillan, London.

ANDERSON, J. (1777), Observations on the Means of Exciting a Spirit of National Industry; Chiefly Intended to Promote the Agriculture, Commerce, Manufactures and Fisheries of Scotland, T. Cadell-C. Elliot, Edinburgh.

ARROW, K. and G. DEBREU (1954), "Existence of equilibrium for a competitive economy", Econometrica, vol. 22, pp. 265-90.

ARROW, K. and F.H. HAHN (1971), General Competitive Analysis, Oliver & Boyd, Edinburgh.

ATKINSON, A.B. (1997), "Bringing income distribution in from the cold", The Economic Journal, vol. 107, pp. 297-321.

ATKINSON, A.B. (1999), "Is rising inequality inevitable? A critique of the transatlantic consensus", Wider Annual Lecture 3, UN/WIDER, Helsinki.

BARANZINI, M. (1991), A Theory of Wealth — Distribution and Accumulation, Clarendon Press, Oxford.

BERTOLA, G. (1993), "Factor shares and savings in endogenous growth", The American Economic Review, vol. 83, pp. 1184-98.

BERTOLA, G. (1995), "Wages profits and theories of growth", in L.L. Pasinetti and R.M. Solow eds, Economic Growth and the Structure of Long Term Development, Macmillan, London, pp. 90-108.

BURMEISTER, E. (1980), Capital Theory and Dynamics, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

CANNAN, E. (1929), A Review of Economic Theory, P.S. King & Son, Ltd, London.

CHAMPERNOWNE, D.G. (1953-54), "The production function and the theory of capital: a comment", The Review of Economic Studies, vol. 21, pp. 118-30.

CHAMPERNOWNE, D.G. and F.A. COWELL (1998), Economic Inequality and Income Distribution, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

CLARK, J.B. (1987), "Ethics of distribution", in P. Newman, J. Eatwell and M. Milgate eds, The New Palgrave Dictionary of Economics, vol. I, pp. 867-69.

CLARK, J.B. (1894), "Ethics of distribution", Palgrave Dictionary of Political Economy.

CLARK, J.B. (1899), The Distribution of Income, Macmillan, New York.

COBB, C.W. and P.H. DOUGLAS (1928), "A theory of production", The American Economic Review, vol. 18, Supplement, March, pp. 139-65.

DEBREU, G. (1959) Theory of Value, Cowles Commission Monograph no. 17, John Wiley, New York.

DOMAR, E. (1946), "Capital expansion, rate of growth and employment", Econometrica, vol. 14, pp. 137-47.

DOUGLAS, P.H. (1934), The Theory of Wages, Macmillan, New York.

FERGUSON, C.E. (1969), The Neoclassical Theory of Production and Distribution, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

FISHER, F.M. (1971), "Aggregate production functions and the explanation of wages: a simulation experiment", The Review of Economics and Statistics, vol. 53, pp. 305- 25.

GALBRAITH, JAMES K. (1998), Created Unequal - The Crisis in American Pay, The Free Press, New York.

GALOR, O. and J. ZEIRA (1993), "Income distribution and macroeconomics", The Review of Economic Studies, vol. 60, pp. 35-52.

GAREGNANI, P. (1960), Il capitale nelle teorie della distribuzione, Giuffrè, Milano (Italian version of a PhD dissertation submitted to the University of Cambridge, December 1958).

GAREGNANI, P. (1990), "Quantity of capital", in J. Eatwell, M. Milgate, P. Newman eds, Capital Theory (essays from, or as a completion to, The New Palgrave Dictionary), Macmillan, London.

GAREGNANI, P. (1998), "Savings, investment and capital in a system of general intertemporal equilibrium", in H.D. Kurz ed., Critical Essays on Piero Sraffa's Legacy in Economics, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 392-445.

HAHN, F.H. (1966), "Equilibrium dynamics with heterogeneous capital goods", The Quarterly Journal of Economics, vol. 53, pp. 633-46.

HAHN, F.H. (1982), "The New-Ricardians", The Cambridge Journal of Economics, vol. 6, pp. 353-74.

HARCOURT, G.H. (1969), "Some Cambridge controversies in the theory of capital", The Journal of Economic Literature, vol. 7, pp. 369-405.

HARCOURT, G.H. (1972), Some Cambridge Controversy in the Theory of Capital, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

HARROD, R.F. (1939), "An essay in dynamic theory", The Economic Journal, vol. 49, pp. 14-33.

HARROD, R.F. (1948), Towards a Dynamic Economics, Macmillan, London.

KALDOR, N. (1955-56), "Alternative theories of distribution", The Review of Economic Studies, vol. 23, pp. 94-100.

KALDOR, N. (1961), "Capital accumulation and economic growth", in D.C. Hague and F.A. Lutz eds, The Theory of Capital, Macmillan, London, pp. 177-222.

KALECKI, M. (1938), "The determinants of distribution of the national income", Econometrica, vol. 6, pp. 97-112.

KALECKI, M. (1942), "A theory of profits", The Economic Journal, vol. 52, pp. 258-67.

KIRMAN, A.P. (1992), "Whom or what does the representative individual represent?", The Journal of Economic Perspectives, vol. 6, pp. 117-36.

KUHN, T.A. (1962), The Structure of Scientific Revolutions, 2nd edn, The University of Chicago Press, Chicago.

KURZ, H.D. (1987), "Capital theory: debates" in P. Newman, J. Eatwell and M. Milgate eds, The New Palgrave Dictionary of Economics, vol. 1, Macmillan, London, pp. 357-63.

LEVHARI, D. (1965), "A nonsubstitution theorem and switching of techniques", The Quarterly Journal of Economics, vol. 79, pp. 98-105.

LEWIS, W.A. (1954), "Economic development with unlimited supply of labour", The Manchester School of Economic and Social Studies, vol. 22, pp. 139-91.

MALTHUS, T.R. (1815), An Inquiry into the Nature and Progress of Rent and the Principles by which it is Regulated, John Murray, London.

MEADE, J.E. (1962), A Neo-Classical Theory of Economic Growth, 2nd edn, Unwin University Books, London.

MUELLER, D.C. (1989), Public Choice, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

PARETO, V. (1897), Cours d'économie politique, tome second, F. Rouge editeur, Lausanne.

PASINETTI, L.L. (1960), "A mathematical formulation of the Ricardian system", The Review of Economic Studies, vol. 27, pp. 78-98.

PASINETTI, L.L. (1962), "Rate of profit and income distribution in relation to the rate of economic growth", The Review of Economic Studies, vol. 29, pp. 267-79.

PASINETTI, L.L. (1966), "Changes in the rate of profits and switches of techniques", Quarterly Journal of Economics, vol. 80, pp. 503-17.

PASINETTI, L.L. (1969), "Switches of technique and the 'rate of return' in capital theory", The Economic Journal, vol. 79, pp. 508-31.

PASINETTI, L.L. (1978), "Wicksell effects and re-switching of techniques in capital theory", The Scandinavian Journal of Economics, vol. 80, pp. 181-89.

PASINETTI, L.L. (1981), Structural Change and Economic Growth - A theoretical essay on the dynamics of the wealth of nations, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

PEROTTI, R. (1992), "Income distribution, politics and growth", The American Economic Review, Papers and Proceedings, vol. 82, no. 2, pp. 311-16.

PERSSON, T. e G. TABELLINI (1994), "Is inequality harmful for growth? Theory and evidence", The American Economic Review, vol. 84, pp. 600-21.

QUADRIO CURZIO, A. (1967), Rendita e distribuzione in un modello economico plurisettoriale, Giuffrè, Milano.

QUADRIO CURZIO, A. (1997), "Rendita", in Enciclopedia delle Scienze Sociali, Istituto della Enciclopedia Italiana, Roma, vol. VII, pp. 395-407.

RAMSEY, F. (1928), "A mathematical theory of saving", Economic Journal, vol. 88, pp. 543-59.

RICARDO, D. (1815), An Essay on the Influence of a Low Price of Corn on the Profits of Stock, John Murray, London.

RICARDO, D. (1951), On the Principles of Political Economy and Taxation, vol. I of The Works and Correspondence of David Ricardo, edited by P. Sraffa with the collaboration of M.H. Dobb, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

ROBINSON, J.V. (1953-54), "The production function and the theory of capital", The Review of Economic Studies, vol. 21, pp. 81-106.

ROSSER, J.B., JR (1991), From Catastrophe to Chaos: A General Theory of Economic Discontinuities, Kluwer, Norwell, Mass.

SAMUELSON, P.A. (1962), "Parable and realism in capital theory: the surrogate production function", Review of Economic Studies, pp. 193-206.

SAMUELSON, P.A. (1964), Economics, an Introductory Analysis, 6th edn, McGraw-Hill Co., New York.

SAMUELSON, P.A., ed. (1966), "Paradoxes in capital theory: a symposium", with contributions by L.L. Pasinetti, D. Levhari, M. Morishima, M. Bruno, E. Burmeister, E. Sheshinski, P. Garegnani, P.A. Samuelson, The Quarterly Journal of Economics, vol. 53, pp. 503-83.

SAMUELSON, P.A. (1966), "A summing up", in Samuelson ed. (1966a), pp. 568-83.

SATO, K. (1974), "The neoclassical postulate and the technology frontier in capital theory", The Quarterly Journal of Economics, vol. 38, pp. 353-84.

SCHEFOLD, B. (1997), "Classical theory and intertemporal equilibrium", in B. Schefold, Normal Prices, Technical Change and Accumulation, Macmillan, London, pp. 425-501.

SCHNEIDER, E. (1934), Theorie der Produktion, Julius Springer Verlag, Wien.

SHAIKH, A. (1974), "Laws of algebra and laws of production: the Humbug production function", The Review of Economics and Statistics, vol. 51, pp. 115-20.

SMITH, A. (1904), An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations, edited by E. Cannan, vol. I, Methuen, London.

SOLOW, R.M. (1955-56), "The production function and the theory of capital", The Review of Economic Studies, vol. 23, pp. 101-08.

SOLOW, R.M. (1956), "A contribution to the theory of economic growth", The Quarterly Journal of Economics, vol. 70, pp. 65-95.

SOLOW, R.M. (1963), Capital Theory and the Rate of Return, North-Holland Publishing Co., Amsterdam.

SOLOW, R.M. (1967), "The interest rate and the transition between techniques", in C.H. Feinstein ed., Socialism, Capitalism and Economic Growth, Essays presented to Maurice Dobb, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 30-39.

SOLOW, R.M. (1990), The Labour Market as a Social Institution, Basil Blackwell, Oxford.

SOLOW, R.M. (2000), "The neoclassical theory of growth and distribution", in this Review, pp. 349-81.

SRAFFA, P. (1960), Production of Commodities by Means of Commodities, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

STIGLITZ J.E. (1969), "Distribution of income and wealth among individuals", Econometrica, vol. 37, pp. 382-97.

SWAN, T.W. (1956), "Economic growth and capital accumulation", The Economic Record, vol. 32, pp. 334-61.

SYLOS LABINI, P. (1974), Saggio sulle classi sociali, Laterza, Bari.

SYLOS LABINI, P. (1995), "Why the interpretation of the Cobb-Douglas production function must be radically changed", Structural Change and Economic Dynamics, vol. 6, pp. 485-504.

THUROW, L.C. (1975), Generating Inequality - Mechanism of Distribution in the U.S. Economy, Basic Books Inc., New York.

TORRENS, R. (1815), An Essay on the External Corn Trade, J. Hatchard, London. WEST, E. (1815), Essay on the Application of Capital to Land, T. Underwood, London.

WICKSELL, K. (1934), Lectures on Political Economy, vol. I, Routledge and Kegan Paul, Ltd, London (original edition Rreliisningar i Nationaleconomi, I, Berlingska Boktrycheriet, Lund).

WICKSELL, K. (1923), "Real capital and interest", Ekonomisk Tidskrift, nos 5-6.

WICKSELL, K. (1934), "Appendix 2" in K. Wicksell, pp. 258-99.

WOOD, A. (1978), A Theory of Pay, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

### Refbacks

- There are currently no refbacks.

Copyright (c) 2016 Luigi L. Pasinetti

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

ISSN 2037-3643

Reg. Tribunale di Roma n.377/2009 del 19/11/2009